opinion When should Jews flee?

Illustrative photo of Ultra-Orthodox Jews in Brooklyn, New York City. (Photo: Mendy Hechtman/Flash90)
Illustrative photo of Ultra-Orthodox Jews in Brooklyn, New York City. (Photo: Mendy Hechtman/Flash90)

It could be the organized boycott of “Zionist establishments,” better known as Jewish-owned restaurants, that happened last week, in Philadelphia’s upscale Rittenhouse Square, or it could be Democratic Socialist Melat Kiros, who promised, in her Colorado victory speech, “We will not wait to end the genocide in Palestine,” or, perhaps it’s the visibly Orthodox Jewish man, brutally attacked, a few days ago, while crossing the street in NY.

The worrying signs are there for all to see. The air of anti-Jewish sentiment, permeating America, is physically targeting people who, just three years ago, were considered to be like everyone else. Today, they are called “the others.”

Whether it’s Democratic politicians, hoping to cash in on the popular trend of scapegoating Jews, or the everyday American who needs to find a reason for soaring prices, blame is being hurled, both domestically and internationally at one race.

It’s a familiar malady for the people who have sought to fit into the society of their birth, doing their best to enhance it rather than be a burden. But that doesn’t really matter, because when push comes to shove, history has shown that it always comes back to bite them, one way or another.

What was always a fear of returning to the dark days of this insidious prejudice has now become visible and audible, as tropes, libels and accusations are spoken publicly, stirring up suspicions and troubling thoughts that Jews may really be the source of all that’s gone wrong.

But this was predictable, the moment Israel became the world’s whipping boy, criticized for having an immoral army, for the crime of defending its citizens from the barbaric massacre that took place on her sovereign land.

Of course, it didn’t stop there. By extension, anyone who bore that same ethnicity, became guilty by association. The next step was the move towards the entire Jewish community, contending that they are responsible for high prices, unaffordability and a weakening economy.

When one Democratic candidate stooped to the level of airing such a message, blaming Jews for the extra money shoppers had to laid out for a “war that bombed children,” that was a new low for American politics – pointing a finger at only one people.

Oddly enough, many Jews will still deny that these dramatic changes have the potential of imperiling them. Perhaps that is the reason Israeli Journalist, Haviv Rettig Gur, asked the question, on a recent podcast, “When should Jews flee?”

For Rettig Gur, who has noticed the virulence of antisemitism, the legitimacy of asking if it’s time to move, is a major consideration. With the presence of the anti-Zionistic fervor he sees among progressives, Rettig Gur points that their conclusion is that Israel should not exist.

Because when universities teach them that colonialism, apartheid, imperialism and ethnic cleansing are all embodied by one state, Israel becomes a pariah among nations.

That kind of deliberate orientation then becomes a driver for the hate, the decision to isolate such an immoral country, and then spills over into justified violence, because bad people must suffer for the evil they are committing.

When things go that far, how long does it take before Jews are told, outright, to leave the country where they have lived all their lives – a land where, perhaps, four or five generations of their family have called home?

With this kind of rapidly-moving progression, will it take much longer before it comes to that. Because when you look back at Jewish history, the pattern was eerily similar, culminating in the need for Jews to leave en masse.

Rettig Gur is paying close attention to the bigotry that is evidenced today in America, as he makes the connection between the past and this present moment, where troubling incidents are escalating.

Nonetheless, he believes that until things turn really violent, Jews will never leave America. To that end, he’s still hoping that America will prove to be the one space that does not turn on its Jews, rendering Zionism wrong.

But with antisemitic incidents being reported on a daily basis, the likelihood that America will remain a safe bastion for Jews is not looking very realistic.

According to a recent article entitled, “The antisemitism horseshoe is playing out in real time — from New York to Paris and beyond,” the targeting of Jews is coming from every direction.

Making the case that “these are not isolated street crimes. They fit a pattern in which visibly Jewish people are targeted, while the broader political conversation treats Jewish safety as secondary or suspect.”

And that’s not strange, because when “more than 1,300 posts on X blaming Jews, Israel, or the Mossad for unrest by using classic conspiracies about Jewish elites,” it’s no wonder that people feel emboldened to attack those they see as monsters, contributing to the downfall of their society.

Driven by fear, ignorance and malice, those who commit antisemitic attacks have fallen into the media trap that was set for them by the people who want to sow suspicion and distrust of Jews.

Print enough lies and accusations, and someone will do what they believe is the morally-correct thing – using violent means to send the message that Jews are the enemy.

As writer Evan Bernstein says, “Jews are cast as alien outsiders who secretly run the banks, the media and the government... Jews are positioned as the hand behind the curtain, then blamed for whichever crisis is underway.”

But how far do things really have to go before hunted-down Jews have waited too long, risking the ability to flee with all their wealth and possessions. It’s a familiar story, one which actually happened to the mega-famed singer, Billy Joel’s grandfather, who was cheated out of the proceeds from the sale of his prosperous German textile factory, all because he waited too long to flee.

By escaping in the middle of the night, he and his family were saved, but it cost them all they had. The lesson learned is never wait until it comes down to a life-or-death choice. The time to flee is before the violent storm, rather than waiting for it to happen.

Logo

Receive latest news & updates

    A message from All Israel News

    Help us educate Christians on a daily basis about what is happening in Israel & the Middle East and why it matters.

    For as little as $10, you can support ALL ISRAEL NEWS, a non-profit media organization that is supported by readers like you.

    DONATE TO ALL ISRAEL NEWS