Angela Merkel says Israel ‘went too far’ in Gaza but defends Germany’s commitment to Jewish state
Former German Chancellor Angela Merkel said on Thursday that Israel “went too far” in Gaza, while stressing that Germany’s historic responsibility to support the Jewish state remains unchanged.
In an interview with the podcast “Coffee and Curses,” Merkel argued that support for Israel does not mean unconditional backing for the government of Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu.
She said criticism of Israel is legitimate but must take into account the country’s security and its right to exist, particularly following the Hamas Oct. 7, 2023, massacre of 1,200 Israelis and the kidnapping of 251 people.
"October 7 was not the date on which Israel attacked the Gaza Strip but the date on which Hamas attacked Israel," Merkel stated. She emphasized that Israel withdrew completely from Gaza in 2005 and that Hamas openly advocates Israel’s destruction.
"We must remember that if we want to have an honest discussion about Israel," she continued.
Merkel said Germany’s commitment to Israel should not be interpreted as a prohibition on criticizing its government.
"Sometimes these statements about Germany's commitment to Israel are interpreted as meaning that we are not allowed to criticize Netanyahu's government or that we support it unconditionally and that is not what I am saying," Merkel argued.
"As chancellor, I criticized this government many times, and there are now many reasons to criticize this government over what is happening in Gaza. So there is no prohibition on criticizing Israel but all criticism must take into account Israel's security and its right to exist," she continued.
"In many respects, particularly regarding the humanitarian situation in Gaza, Israel went too far," Merkel claimed. "There was a need to recognize and speak openly about proportionality, especially regarding the suffering of the civilian population and the supply of food."
"We heard very few people from Gaza speaking critically about Hamas after October 7. After all, this was an event that made life dangerous for them as well," Merkel said.
At the same time, Merkel acknowledged the difficult decisions Israeli leaders face when confronting terrorist groups like Hamas, which use civilians as human shields in violation of international law.
"I think I have never had to solve such a difficult problem. When there is a bunker full of Hamas members beneath a kindergarten or hospital, and I know I have to destroy what is above it to eliminate them, that is an extremely complicated task and decision, because as prime minister, you have to protect your citizens. That is what people in Germany expect from their leaders," Merkel assessed.
The dilemma was illustrated earlier this week again when the Israeli military struck senior Hamas operatives, including a Hamas brigade commander, who were hiding in a Gaza hospital.
Merkel also criticized what she described as disproportionate media attention to the Gaza war, contrasting it with limited coverage of humanitarian disasters and alleged war crimes in countries such as Sudan and Yemen.
"If you look at what is written and said about Yemen, where millions of children are suffering from hunger," Merkel assessed, "or what is written and said about Sudan, it is clear that there is no proportionality, because there is almost no discussion about what is happening there."
Germany has emerged as one of Israel’s strongest allies in the European Union. However, as in many other Western nations, antisemitic incidents have soared in Germany since the Hamas attack.
Popular article:
interview Easter message of resurrection hope amid war at Jerusalem's Garden Tomb
biblical commentary Let my people go: a Passover message for today
4 IDF soldiers killed, 2 wounded in fighting in southern Lebanon, as Israel eliminates dozens of Hezbollah terrorists
Receive latest news & updates
A message from All Israel News
Help us educate Christians on a daily basis about what is happening in Israel & the Middle East and why it matters.
For as little as $10, you can support ALL ISRAEL NEWS, a non-profit media organization that is supported by readers like you.
Latest articles:
Jewish heirs seek to block $180 million Van Gogh auction over alleged Nazi forced sale
Toward a unity gov’t? Likud, Eisenkot’s Yashar party hold first meeting as Liberman doubles down on opposition
Last Righteous Among the Nations living in Israel, dies at 91
Palestine Strategy Group unveils plan to subvert Christian Zionist organizations, turn them against Israel - report
YouTuber Tyler Oliveira sparks outrage with misleading ‘Jews-only’ claims about Florida Jewish community