Mossad abducted 2 Iranian generals, killed one in decades-long search for missing Israeli navigator Ron Arad – report

NYT report suggest ‘confirmation bias’ prevented Mossad from accepting evidence against Iranian involvement

Missing Israeli Air Force officer Ron Arad, photographed by Amal militants in Lebanon in 1987 (Photo: Wikipedia)
Missing Israeli Air Force officer Ron Arad, photographed by Amal militants in Lebanon in 1987 (Photo: Wikipedia)

Israeli intelligence agents kidnapped two Iranian generals, killing one, in an attempt to find a navigator downed over Lebanon, believing the Islamic Regime knew his location, the New York Times reported.

For several decades, Israeli intelligence agencies operated on the suspicion that Iran was either holding or had information on downed Israeli navigator Ron Arad, who disappeared in Lebanon in 1986.

That perception persisted, even as other intelligence indicated that Iran may not have been involved.

According to the NYT report, operating on the basis of this assessment, Israel launched covert operations, kidnapped senior Iranian officials, applied political pressure and invested enormous intelligence efforts to track down Arad’s location.

The Times report, based on interviews with dozens of senior Israeli, Iranian, and American officials, showed that intelligence assessments began to indicate that Arad was never transferred to Iran, and in fact, may have died only a couple of years after his capture, in the village of Nabi Chit, where he was held.

That belief that Iran was behind Arad’s disappearance led to the capture of several individuals known or believed to have been involved in Arad’s detainment.

Israeli commandos apprehended Mustafa Dirani, chief of security for the Shia Lebanese militia Amal, which had caught Arad after he ejected from his badly damaged plane over southern Lebanon.

Dirani told his Israeli interrogators that he had placed Arad with a loyal family in Nabi Chit. One night, the men guarding Arad left the house suddenly. When they returned, Arad was missing, and no one had seen him since.

Despite multiple interrogations, including some in which Dirani alleged that he was physically and sexually tortured, he claimed that an Iranian official told him the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps had captured the Israeli navigator, taking him to a prison in Iran.

The Mossad never corroborated this account, and some agents assessed that Dirani told the interrogators what they wanted to hear.

Israel began to put political pressure on Iran to either hand over Arad or provide information on his whereabouts.

Former Iranian Vice President Mohammad Ali Abtahi told the Times, “The issue of Ron Arad followed us everywhere.”

In 2004, Israel agreed with Hezbollah to release a high-profile Lebanese prisoner, in exchange for information about Arad.

Hezbollah asked the IRGC for help in locating information about Arad. An investigation by the two determined that the Israeli navigator died in Nabi Chit in 1988 and was likely buried somewhere nearby.

The Iranians gave the results of the investigation to German mediators, who passed them on to Israel.

Israeli intelligence, however, saw the participation of the IRGC as proof of Iranian involvement in Arad’s disappearance.

“The fact that a highly important Iranian general flew to Lebanon from Tehran to bring a unique body of knowledge and help Hezbollah locate the grave only added to our deep conviction that Iran was behind this event,” Raz Zimmt, a former Israeli military intelligence analyst involved in the search for Arad, told the Times.

Zimmt later changed his view, telling the Times that there was “a natural inclination to pin everything on the regime in Tehran.”

A 2006 report by Israel’s Shin Bet security agency concluded that reports that Arad had been taken to Iran “were incorrect and were based on serious mistakes in reading the intelligence that had been collected, or on unreliable or erroneous information.”

The report was reportedly rejected by Mossad.

Instead, the agency launched an operation to kidnap Iranian Quds Force General Ali Reza Asgari, a former Iranian Deputy Defense Minister, the Times reported.

Asgari vanished from his hotel in Istanbul in December 2006.

According to three former U.S. officials who worked closely with Israel, Mossad agents abducted Asgari, interrogated him for weeks on a boat in the Black Sea regarding any potential connection to Arad’s disappearance; and once it became clear that he held no such information, they killed him.

Israeli officials later confirmed to U.S. officials that Asgari was killed, the Times reported.

Israel has consistently denied any involvement in Asgari’s disappearance.

Israel declared Ron Arad dead in 2008.

Former Shin Bet official Yitzhak Ilan told the Times, in an interview with a newspaper before his death in 2020, that, even prior to the operation, he had realized the answer to the Ron Arad case did not lie with the Iranians.

Avi Kalo, a retired senior Israeli military officer, wrote a detailed report in 2016, which was delivered to then Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, stating that Arad had most likely died in Lebanon in 1988.

However, according to the Times, the Mossad did not abandon its belief that Tehran was involved.

In September 2021, Israeli intelligence operatives, posing as delivery workers, abducted Iranian General Abdollah Sabri while he was out for a morning run in the Syrian capital’s diplomatic quarter.

Sabri, who had previously been involved in the search for Arad in Lebanon, was drugged, placed inside a large refrigerated container and transported to Israel for interrogation, The Times reported. After an extensive interrogation, he was reportedly left disoriented on a street in Johannesburg, South Africa.

Iranian officials told the Times his interrogators were only interested in Ron Arad.

David Barnea, the then-head of the Mossad, described the operation as "brave and daring" but ultimately a "failure." According to his associates, he instructed agency personnel to shred all material gathered on the case.

The Times investigation indicates that the prevailing Israeli assessment, that Iran was responsible for Arad’s disappearance, was based on questionable testimony and “confirmation bias.” It also ignored repeated evidence to the contrary.

For instance, in 1992, an Iranian doctor claimed to Mossad operative Israel Perlov that he had treated Arad in Tehran and Lebanon. Polygraph tests were inconclusive, and the doctor disappeared after being offered money in exchange for proof.

In March, IDF commandos raided a cemetery in Nabi Chit and excavated a grave in search of Arad’s remains, without conclusive results.

“The operation carried out last night did not produce what we were looking for,” Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said at the time, “but the commitment of Israel, and my personal commitment, to completing all missions concerning our prisoners and missing persons is absolute.”

The IDF still classifies Ron Arad as missing in action and as a fallen soldier whose burial place is unknown.

Logo

Receive latest news & updates

    A message from All Israel News

    Help us educate Christians on a daily basis about what is happening in Israel & the Middle East and why it matters.

    For as little as $10, you can support ALL ISRAEL NEWS, a non-profit media organization that is supported by readers like you.

    DONATE TO ALL ISRAEL NEWS