NYC councilman warns anti-Zionist rhetoric in City Hall is fueling antisemitism
A New York City councilman is warning that anti-Zionist rhetoric from elected officials is contributing to rising antisemitism, criticizing Mayor Zohran Mamdani and other city leaders for failing to recognize the connection between hostility toward Israel and discrimination against Jews.
Democrat Eric Dinowitz, who chairs the New York City Council’s Jewish Caucus and co-chairs the council’s Bipartisan Task Force to Combat Antisemitism, made the comments in an interview Tuesday, arguing that efforts to address antisemitism are incomplete when they ignore anti-Zionism as a source of hostility toward the Jewish community.
“That’s been the mantra of the far left – the only antisemitism that exists is from the far right, and that isn’t accurate,” Dinowitz said in an interview with the Times of Israel.
Citing a recent decision by Hunter College to cancel a student-led event because it included participation by a Jewish club, he said, “This isn’t antisemitism coming from the right and to exclude it is to ignore a very real source of anxiety and fear within the Jewish community.”
According to statistics published by the New York Police Department (NYPD), the city’s Jewish community is targeted in hate crimes at rates far higher than any other minority group. The data also point to rising anti-Jewish discrimination in workplaces and on university campuses.
Mamdani has condemned antisemitism while making opposition to Zionism a centerpiece of his political message. He has defended comparisons of Zionism to the Nazi regime of the 1930s and 1940s, while also expressing agreement with the position that Zionism is a form of racism.
A plan launched by his administration in September to combat antisemitism drew sharp criticism from Jewish leaders for failing to address the relationship between antisemitism and anti-Zionism.
“The report they released didn’t even mention Zionism,” Dinowitz said this week. “Anti-Zionism is often a smokescreen for anti-Jewish sentiment and anti-Jewish actions and to ignore that and exclude that possibility is to ignore the realities that so many in the Jewish community are facing.”
Dinowitz also criticized Mamdani’s repeated anti-Israel rhetoric, including his stated intention to arrest Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu if he visited New York for the United Nations General Assembly earlier this year.
Dinowitz said such statements, which repeatedly single out Israel, “do give license for people to express themselves in a way that isn’t healthy.”
He also discussed an incident in which Mamdani was heckled by anti-Israel protesters while attending a vigil for the victims of the Hamas massacre on Oct. 7, 2023. Mamdani remained at the event rather than leaving.
“It’s the job of elected officials, the mayor more than anyone – you’re gonna get heckled. That he stayed there, I think, was the right move,” Dinowitz said. “What’s not being discussed is that relationship between anti-Zionism and antisemitism. It’s impossible to ignore that.”
Speaking about his own district, Dinowitz said, “People in the Bronx just want to get along. They want to work together. It means the world to us to know that we’re not alone.”
But not all Jewish New Yorkers share that sense of optimism.
Chaim P., an Orthodox rabbi who has lived in northern New Jersey his entire life and serves on the staff at Yeshiva University, also works with several Jewish organizations in New York City. He told ALL ISRAEL NEWS that the situation has deteriorated dramatically since the Oct. 7 attacks:
“I’ve been in New York City almost every day of my life for 60 years and it’s never been like this before. There have always been the occasional anti-Semitic incident here and there but since Oct. 7 it’s like someone flipped a switch somewhere and it’s everywhere, all the time.”
He said the growing hostility has prompted people in his community to consider leaving the United States for Israel.
“Everyone I know is talking about making Aliyah before the next Holocaust happens here. I think I’m probably too old for that sort of thing but I’m encouraging my sons and other younger people I know to seriously think about it,” he said.
Popular article:
interview Easter message of resurrection hope amid war at Jerusalem's Garden Tomb
biblical commentary Let my people go: a Passover message for today
4 IDF soldiers killed, 2 wounded in fighting in southern Lebanon, as Israel eliminates dozens of Hezbollah terrorists
Receive latest news & updates
A message from All Israel News
Help us educate Christians on a daily basis about what is happening in Israel & the Middle East and why it matters.
For as little as $10, you can support ALL ISRAEL NEWS, a non-profit media organization that is supported by readers like you.
Latest articles:
Anti-Arab attacks: Mosque set ablaze and vandalized, 8 wounded in car ramming by Jewish attacker
Palestinian Authority seeks UNESCO recognition for Jerusalem bagel as Palestinian heritage
1,000 days since Israeli child Haymanut Kasau disappeared, family still has no information
CENTCOM chief Cooper visits Israel, meets with IDF & Mossad heads amid reports of possible Iran strikes
Israel’s attorney general orders halt to E1 settlement construction until new gov’t is established