opinion WATCH VIDEO: Gadi & Bibi should form a broad national unity government that excludes extremists on both right and left
Israel urgently needs more unity, not more division
JERUSALEM, ISRAEL – Neither side got what they wanted in Israel's recent elections.
Therefore, there is no obvious path for either Prime Minister Benjamin "Bibi" Netanyahu or Change Bloc leader Gadi Eisenkot to form a stable and secure government of at least 61 seats.
It's true that 67 members of the Knesset (MKs) support Eisenkot and want to remove Bibi from power.
That's why President Isaac Herzog gave the mandate to form the next government to Eisenkot.
The problem is that 19 of those MKs are Arab Israelis who are members of communist and radical Islamist parties (comprising the Joint List) or of Ra'am whose leader – Mansour Abbas – has been inching his party towards the Israeli mainstream but inexplicably cannot bring himself to publicly call Hamas a terrorist organization.
Let's be clear: Being an Arab should never disqualify an Israeli from helping form an Israeli government.
But refusing to name and shame Hamas for being a terrorist group – and refusing to utterly reject and condemn Hamas for their barbaric and genocidal attacks on Oct. 7 – is disqualifying.
That's why Eisenkot can't create a government with 67 seats by asking these Arab MKs to formally join with him.
Netanyahu, meanwhile, only has 43 MKs backing him, a dramatic drop from the 68 MKs he had with him before the elections.
So, where does that leave us?
I believe the best way forward is for Gadi to form a broad national unity government with Bibi that leaves out the extremist parties on both the right (such as the Jewish Power party with its notorious firebrand, MK Itamar Ben Gvir) and the left.
Gadi and Bibi should only allow ultra-Orthodox Jewish parties to join if they finally agree to allow their young religious men to either serve in the IDF or perform some form of national service.
Assuming the ultra-Orthodox parties will continue refusing to have their sons serve the country the way everyone else required to, then Gadi and Bibi could still form a stable and secure government of mature and responsible leaders with 67 MKs.
• Eisenkot's Yashar party has 21 seats.
• Netanyahu's Likud party has 27 seats.
• Former Prime Minister Naftali Bennett and his B'Yachad party has 12 seats.
• Former Defense Minister Avigdor Liberman's Yisrael Beitenu party has 7 seats.
True, these opposition leaders have deep personal animosities towards Bibi – they all have worked very closely with Netanyahu and came to distrust him.
Of course, the resentments flow in both directions.
Netanyahu once hired Liberman to be his chief of staff but that ended in acrimony.
Netanyahu later hired Bennett to be his chief of staff but that also ended in acrimony.
Years later, Netanyahu appointed Eisenkot to lead the Israeli military. But they, too, had a serious falling out.
So, it would be a difficult government to form, run and create unity within.
Nevertheless, what other options are there?
Going back to elections will be expensive and exhausting.
That's why I believe that forming a broad national unity government is the best-case scenario – not perfect but better than the alternatives.
In the video above, I go into more detail about the reasons and the benefits for creating such a government.
I encourage you to watch it – share it with others – and pray for the Lord to show much grace and mercy to Israel's people and leaders at this critical time.
Support our independent, on-the-ground reporting from Israel. Become a $5/month Ally.
Popular article:
interview Easter message of resurrection hope amid war at Jerusalem's Garden Tomb
biblical commentary Let my people go: a Passover message for today
4 IDF soldiers killed, 2 wounded in fighting in southern Lebanon, as Israel eliminates dozens of Hezbollah terrorists
Receive latest news & updates
A message from All Israel News
Help us educate Christians on a daily basis about what is happening in Israel & the Middle East and why it matters.
For as little as $10, you can support ALL ISRAEL NEWS, a non-profit media organization that is supported by readers like you.
Latest articles:
Board of Peace could return Gaza responsibility to UN if Israel continues stalling peace plan, official warns
Netanyahu thinks new Iran war is ‘unavoidable’ as Change Bloc appears divided on Iran issue, unity gov't
IDF completes one-day tunnel clearing operation beyond Yellow Line in central Gaza, 1st incursion since ceasefire start
Feature ‘Israel, you are not alone’ – Christians pray outside Israeli Embassy in Seoul
Quantum technology could threaten Israel’s military edge, INSS report warns