opinion Being anti-Zionist does not make you pro-Palestinian
My recent visit to Japan left me with a deep appreciation for the country and its people. I encountered kindness and hospitality throughout my trip, and it was easy to understand why so many Israelis love visiting. That warmth is what I will remember most.
During my trip Japan, I came across pro-Palestinian protests and tried to speak with some of the demonstrators. I was interested in what had brought them out in solidarity with people living so far away, and whether we could have a conversation about what might actually improve Palestinian lives.
The people I approached were unwilling to engage. When I raised Palestinian suffering under Hamas, that did not seem to interest them either. What surprised me was the contrast between the openness I had experienced throughout my visit and the closed conversation I encountered there. Those brief encounters could hardly represent Japan, or an entire protest movement. Yet I came away with the uncomfortable impression that, for the people I had approached, opposing Israel mattered more than discussing how to help Palestinians.
That experience stayed with me. It sharpened a question that I believe anyone claiming to support the Palestinian people should be willing to answer:
If Palestinians could live safer, freer and more prosperous lives tomorrow, but Israel would continue to exist, would you consider that progress?
The answer should come without hesitation. Yet that question exposes a distinction too often lost in this debate: wanting Israel to lose is not the same as wanting Palestinians to thrive.
As an Arab Israeli, I find that distinction personal. The conflict being protested on a street in Japan concerns the place I call home. The people living here deserve the freedom to decide that they want a different life, even when their choices disappoint those claiming to speak for them.
Hostility toward Israel is too often accepted as evidence of solidarity with Arabs. But it tells me very little about whether someone supports our freedom to reject armed factions, criticize our leaders or pursue a compromise that allows our children to grow up in peace.
Lebanon offers a revealing example.
A September 2026 survey by Statistics Lebanon, conducted among 800 Lebanese Shiite adults, found that 66.4 percent supported transferring Hezbollah’s weapons to the Lebanese state. Another 71.1 percent believed decisions about war and peace should rest exclusively with the state. These respondents came from the community that has long formed Hezbollah’s core constituency.
These findings challenge the easy assumption that defending Hezbollah’s arsenal means defending the wishes of the people it claims to protect. People do not owe anyone another generation of sacrifice to prove their commitment to “resistance.”
The question is whether fighting Israel is enough to make an armed campaign worthy of support. What weight belongs to the people who must endure its consequences? What happens when they decide that the promised protection has become an unbearable burden?
For a commentator abroad, resistance can remain an argument. For a family in southern Lebanon, it can determine whether they return home, whether their business survives and whether their children have a future there. Their judgment should carry more weight than the satisfaction of watching someone strike at Israel.
Syria exposes the same moral problem in an even harsher light.
Hezbollah fought to sustain Bashar al-Assad’s regime. Its confrontation with Israel did not prevent it from helping a dictator repress Arabs across the border. The Syrian Network for Human Rights has documented more than 202,000 civilians killed by the former regime since 2011, alongside torture and enforced disappearances. It describes the regime’s violations as contributing to the displacement of millions.
The standard must remain the treatment of people, including when their suffering complicates our preferred political narrative.
That applies just as directly to Palestinians.
In May 2025, Amnesty International documented threats, interrogations and beatings by Hamas security forces against Palestinian protesters in Gaza. Demonstrators demanded an end to Israeli attacks and displacement while also criticizing Hamas; some called for its rule to end. These were Palestinians expressing anger at more than one source of their suffering.
Anyone claiming solidarity with them should defend their right to do so. They should not have to soften their criticism of Hamas because an Israeli might quote it.
Palestinians have political agency. They are entitled to disagree with one another, reject the people governing them and pursue solutions that outsiders might consider insufficiently revolutionary.
The real test comes when Palestinian welfare and an activist’s preferred strategy pull in different directions. Would you support a compromise that improved Palestinian lives if it also improved Israeli security? Would you welcome reconstruction, accountable government and coexistence if those developments weakened the case for permanent confrontation?
If every improvement becomes suspect because Israel might also benefit, Palestinian welfare has slipped out of first place.
Criticize Israel as forcefully as you wish. Demand accountability from its government and military. Advocate for Palestinian freedom, security and self-determination. None of that requires romanticizing Hezbollah or excusing dictatorships.
Palestinians deserve to raise children, choose leaders, speak freely and plan lives beyond the next war. Their suffering must never become something outsiders are willing to prolong because it serves the struggle against Israel.
Being anti-Zionist does not automatically make you pro-Palestinian.
If you would rather see Palestinians continue suffering than accept a future in which they and Israelis can both thrive, you should stop calling yourself their ally.
Popular article:
interview Easter message of resurrection hope amid war at Jerusalem's Garden Tomb
biblical commentary Let my people go: a Passover message for today
4 IDF soldiers killed, 2 wounded in fighting in southern Lebanon, as Israel eliminates dozens of Hezbollah terrorists
Receive latest news & updates
A message from All Israel News
Help us educate Christians on a daily basis about what is happening in Israel & the Middle East and why it matters.
For as little as $10, you can support ALL ISRAEL NEWS, a non-profit media organization that is supported by readers like you.
Latest articles:
Following multiple attacks on Arab towns in Judea & Samaria, Eisenkot condemns 'Jewish terrorism’
ANALYSIS Can Israel and the US finish the job if they attack Iran again?
interview ‘Antisemitism is eroding liberal democracy’: UK Lord Eric Pickles sounds alarm over growing Jew hatred
68% of Republican primary voters in 4 key states view Israel favorably – poll
Israel brings 250 young American leaders from all 50 states in order to strengthen ties with next generation